First year: 2015
All-Time Regular Season Record: 53-51
All-Time Postseason Record: 4-4
Last UFA Postseason: 2019/Div. Championship — def. Chicago (21-20); lost to Indianapolis (23-17)
| Year | Record | Goals | Goals Against |
| 2015 | 12-2* | 410 | 294 |
| 2016 | 10-4* | 355 | 296 |
| 2017 | 9-5* | 322 | 310 |
| 2018 | 4-10 | 275 | 332 |
| 2019 | 8-4* | 259 | 227 |
| 2021 | 1-11 | 228 | 289 |
| 2022 | 4-8 | 225 | 249 |
| 2023 | 5-7 | 236 | 226 |
*- Qualified for playoffs
2015
Record: 12-2, Finished 2nd in Central Division
Points/Game: 29.3 (T-1st out of 25)
Opp. Points/Game: 21.0 (5th out of 25)
Assists Leader: Tyler Degirolamo (86)
Goals Leader: Ethan Beardsley (69)
Blocks Leader: Anson Reppermund (22)
2016
Record: 10-4, Finished 2nd in Central Division
Points/Game: 25.4 (7th out of 26)
Opp. Points/Game: 21.1 (7th out of 26)
Assists Leader: Alex Thorne (33)
Goals Leader: David Vatz & Ethan Beardsley (45)
Blocks Leader: Anson Reppermund (34)
2017
Record: 9-5, Finished 3rd in Central Division
Points/Game: 23.0 (13th out of 24)
Opp. Points/Game: 22.1 (10th out of 24)
Assists Leader: Pat Earles (50)
Goals Leader: Mark Fedorenko (33)
Blocks Leader: Anson Reppermund (30)
2018
Record: 4-10, Finished 5th in Central Division
Points/Game: 19.6 (22nd out of 23)
Opp. Points/Game: 23.7 (15th out of 23)
Assists Leader: Max Sheppard (64)
Goals Leader: Jimmy Towle (42)
Blocks Leader: Jon DeAmicis (14)
2019
Record: 8-4, Finished 2nd in Central Division
Points/Game: 21.29 (10th out of 21)
Opp. Points/Game: 19.29 (T-3rd out of 21)
Assists Leader: Max Sheppard (68)
Goals Leader: Max Sheppard (61)
Blocks Leader: Anson Reppermund (26)
2021
Record: 1-11, Finished 8th in Atlantic Division
Points/Game: 19.0 (17th out of 22)
Opp. Points/Game: 24.1 (20th out of 22)
Assists Leader: Max Sheppard (37)
Goals Leader: CJ Colicchio (43)
Blocks Leader: CJ Colicchio (15)
Throwing Yards Leader: Thomas Edmonds (2784)
Receiving Yards Leader: Max Sheppard (3134)
2022
Record: 4-8, Finished 5th in Central Division
Points/Game: 18.8 (20th out of 25)
Opp. Points/Game: 20.8 (13th out of 25)
Assists Leader: Max Sheppard (32)
Goals Leader: Max Sheppard (34)
Blocks Leader: CJ Colicchio, Max Sheppard (11)
Throwing Yards Leader: Clint McSherry (3431)
Receiving Yards Leader: Max Sheppard (3161)
2023
Record: 5-7, Finished 4th in Central Division
Points/Game: 19.7 (13th out of 24)
Opp. Points/Game: 18.9 (T-10th out of 24)
Assists Leader: Max Sheppard (50)
Goals Leader: Carl Johnson (45)
Blocks Leader: Steve Mogielski (14)
Throwing Yards Leader: Jonathan Mast (3901)
Receiving Yards Leader: Max Sheppard (3269)
